Written By Jennie Edgar
 

We Have Always Lived in the Castle
by shirley JACKSON

Shirley Jackson

THE RECAP

The power of We Have Always Lived in the Castle lies in its precise ambiguity. Shirley Jackson's final novel presents itself as a simple story of two sisters living in isolation, but beneath this surface runs a complex examination of family loyalty, social persecution, and the nature of evil. Our discussion centered on how Jackson transforms familiar Gothic elements into something uniquely unsettling - a horror story where the monsters might be our protagonists, and where the real terror lies not in the supernatural but in the mundane cruelty of human nature. Here, we recap the major themes, the analyses you ought to know, some topics of conversation, and links to elsewhere. From all of us behind the scenes at So Textual, we hope you enjoy! 

Merricat’s Spell

"My name is Mary Katherine Blackwood... I like my sister Constance, and Richard Plantagenet, and Amanita phalloides, the death-cup mushroom. Everyone else in my family is dead." From its first lines, Castle casts a particular kind of spell. Merricat's voice gets into your head. It's a child's voice speaking of death, an innocent's voice harboring violence, a madwoman's voice making perfect sense. The death-cup mushroom sits there between a medieval king and a beloved sister, as if poison were just another item in a girl's list of favorite things. This is how Jackson works - she doesn't announce horror, she slips it into the ordinary, lets it grow like a fungus between her sentences.

Jackson constructs time like a trap in WHALITC. The novel's present unfolds over mere weeks, but Merricat's narration warps linear progression. She speaks of Tuesday rituals and the poisoned dinner years ago with the same immediacy, collapsing past and present into a single, haunted moment. The effect is disorienting - we're never quite sure if we're reading a contemporary drama or an ancient curse, a crime story or a fairy tale gone wrong. Through Merricat's eyes, a simple walk to the grocery store carries the weight of an epic journey, while a family massacre becomes as mundane as washing dishes.

Psychological Architectures

The psychological complexity of the Blackwood sisters forms the novel's foundation. Merricat's magical thinking—her buried talismans, protective words, and elaborate rituals—represents more than mere eccentricity. It constitutes a complete symbolic system for managing anxiety and exerting control over an hostile environment. Her persecution complex paradoxically creates the very persecution she fears, yet her paranoia proves justified when the villagers eventually turn violent.

Constance's agoraphobia and excessive domesticity present a different but equally complex response to trauma. Her transformation of the domestic sphere into both prison and sanctuary reflects broader patterns of female response to patriarchal violence. The kitchen becomes her domain of power, where she can exercise control through the preparation and preservation of food—the same medium through which her family was destroyed.

The sisters' relationship exists in a space between protection and enablement, love and codependency. Their final situation - the transformation of their ruined house into a kind of twisted paradise - resists simple moral interpretation. Jackson presents their fate as both triumph and tragedy, a perfect imprisonment that might also be perfect freedom.

Cultural Context

Jackson's work emerges from multiple literary traditions while transforming them into something uniquely modern. The Gothic elements are clear: the decaying mansion, the family curse, the hostile town. But Jackson subverts these tropes by locating the horror in social dynamics rather than supernatural forces. The Blackwood mansion joins the House of Usher and House of the Seven Gables in the American Gothic architectural pantheon, but it survives rather than collapses, becoming a symbol of feminine resistance rather than patriarchal decay.

The influence of New England folk horror traditions is evident in the novel's treatment of isolation and community suspicion. Jackson draws on the region's history of witch trials and religious persecution, but transforms these historical elements into a critique of mid-20th century social conformity. The villagers' transformation from passive-aggressive tormentors to violent mob reveals how little has changed since colonial times.

The Biopic

The 2020 film "Shirley," while taking significant liberties with biography, provides an interesting lens through which to view WHALITC. The film's portrayal of Jackson's creative process suggests how personal experience with social anxiety and domestic confinement might have informed the novel's psychological insights. The parallel between Rose, the fictional character in "Shirley," and Merricat illuminates how young women's resistance to social pressure can take both creative and destructive forms.

Textual Mechanics and Symbolic Structures 

Food and poison emerge as central motifs throughout the novel. The family's fatal meal, Constance's careful food preservation, the villagers' destruction of the stored food, and the final sugar cookies all carry profound symbolic weight. Food becomes a medium for both nurture and destruction, love and hate, preservation and decay. The destruction of the family's preserves by the villagers represents not just physical violence but an attack on their history and independence.

Jackson's use of domestic details to create horror is particularly effective. The simple act of Merricat walking to town becomes an exercise in mounting dread. Common objects—a book, a teacup, a sugar bowl—acquire talismanic significance. This transformation of the ordinary into the ominous occurs without any supernatural elements, making the horror more immediate and inescapable.

Contemporary Resonance

The novel's exploration of isolation, persecution, and female agency remains powerfully relevant. Its portrayal of how quickly a community can turn to violence feels particularly prescient in an era of online mob behavior and social media harassment. The sisters' retreat into their own world, while extreme, reflects contemporary questions about withdrawal from hostile social environments.

The economic subtext—the tension between the wealthy Blackwoods and the resentful townspeople - speaks to ongoing discussions about class division and social inequality. Jackson's portrayal of how privilege can become both shield and target illuminates current debates about wealth, power, and social responsibility.

Enduring Relevance

We Have Always Lived in the Castle speaks to contemporary readers because it addresses timeless themes: the price of difference, the power of family bonds, and the violence that lurks beneath civil society. But it also feels surprisingly modern in its treatment of mental illness, trauma, and female agency.

The novel's exploration of sisterhood and female solidarity in the face of patriarchal violence resonates strongly with current feminist discourse. Merricat and Constance's final situation—their transforming of destruction into a kind of twisted domestic paradise—sparked debate about whether the ending represents triumph or tragedy.

Paths Through the Castle—a Reading List

Gothic Foundations

  • The Fall of the House of Usher by Edgar Allan Poe: While Poe's mansion crumbles under the weight of masculine guilt, Jackson's Blackwood house stands defiant—a transformation of Gothic architecture from tomb to fortress that reveals how women might repurpose the spaces meant to contain them.

  • The Yellow Wallpaper by Charlotte Perkins Gilman: Like Merricat, Gilman's narrator creates an alternate reality within domestic confinement—read these works together to see how women's "madness" often speaks clearer truth than society's "sanity."

  • The Turn of the Screw by Henry James: James's governess and Merricat share a talent for making us question everything we read—these narrators force us to confront how much of horror lies in the eye of the beholder.

Contemporary Reads

  • Her Body and Other Parties by Carmen Maria Machado: Machado takes Jackson's legacy of domestic horror into the 21st century, showing how women's bodies and minds remain battlegrounds - these stories feel like what Merricat might write if she lived today.

  • Housekeeping by Marilynne Robinson: Robinson's novel about two sisters living in isolation shares Castle's DNA - it shows how women can transform abandonment into sovereignty, how a house becomes both refuge and world unto itself. Like the Blackwoods, Robinson's characters choose to step outside society's boundaries, finding freedom in what others might call madness.

  • The Haunting of Hill House by Shirley Jackson: While Castle traps us inside Merricat's perspective, Hill House shows us isolation from the outside - together, they form a complete picture of Jackson's genius for turning architecture into psychology.For those interested in further reading of articles, secondary sources, and the best of literary culture on the internet, we compiled a short list of “petite recommendations.”

Theoretical Frameworks

  • The Weird and the Eerie by Mark Fisher: Fisher's concepts help explain why WHALITC feels so unsettling - it's not about what happens, but about the way normal things (houses, families, village life) become suddenly strange and threatening.

  • The Madwoman in the Attic by Sandra Gilbert and Susan Gubar: This foundational work of feminist literary criticism illuminates why Merricat and Constance's self-imposed exile feels like both resistance and triumph - it reveals how women writers have long used Gothic spaces to express rage against patriarchal confinement. Castle becomes clearer when we see how it fits into this tradition of women turning architectural imprisonment into artistic power.

  • American Gothic by Charles L. Crow: Crow places Castle in a tradition of American stories about family curses, small-town persecution, and the price of difference - context that makes the Blackwoods' isolation feel almost inevitable.

Read More, Elsewhere

Conclusion

We Have Always Lived in the Castle endures because it captures something fundamental about the relationship between individual and society, between love and destruction, between the need for connection and the desire for isolation. Jackson's achievement lies in making these universal themes feel simultaneously personal and mythic. The novel serves as both psychological case study and social allegory, domestic drama and cultural critique. Its horror emerges not from supernatural elements but from the recognition that the most terrifying monsters might be ourselves, and that sometimes the only response to a hostile world is to build our own castle and live in it, always.

 
 
 
 
Jennie Edgar
Next